Fujifilm X-Series Dynamic Range Settings
- György
- March 3, 2021
- Advanced, Photography, Tests
Fujifilm X-t3 Dynamic range (DR) settings
All digital cameras try to help photographers record with high-contrast, wide dynamic range scenes without having to sacrifice highlight or shadow details. The Fujifilm X-series cameras (including the X-T3, X-T30 and X-T4) call these Dynamic Range optimisation settings DR100, DR200 and DR400.
There are many excellent articles describing how the Fujifilm DR settings work. I wanted to see what they actually do to photos.
The test was prompted by a discussion in one of the several Fujifilm X-T3 groups on Facebook. Someone asked what “DR400” was, someone tried to explain and in the generic confusion someone else claimed that this setting “worked” on RAW files as well as JPEGs.
This claim is absolutely wrong.
Since seeing is believing (*no, actually, believing is seeing) I decided to shoot a quick test, and analyse what Fujifilm’s DR100, DR200 and DR400 settings actually changed in otherwise identical JPEG and RAW files.
The Setup - CAmera settings
The photos were shot with a Fujifilm X-T3 and a 23mm, f/1.4 lens. It was evening, so the image was shot in artificial light (warm white LED) at f/2.8 and with a shutter speed of 1/15 of a second (camera resting on a tripod, exposures taken with a self-release timer of 2 seconds).
The only variables adjusted were ISO and the camera’s Dynamic Range optimisation setting. Fujifilm X-series cameras call this “DR100”, “DR200” and “DR400”.
I shot three sets of RAW and Fine JPEG image pairs. Between each set I doubled the ISO (400, 800 and 1600) and for each ISO setting I shot an image at DR100, DR200 and DR400. The JPEGs use the Standard Fujifilm film simulation mode.
Changing the ISO meant, that according to the camera’s light meter the first set was a bit underexposed at ISO 400 (EV -0.7). The second set was slightly overexposed at ISO 800 (EV +0.3) with the third series being EV +1.3 at ISO 1600.
That meant that ISO 1600 was already producing images where some of the highlights of the scene were losing detail due to overexposure.
After the shoot I imported the images into two separate image editing programs, Adobe Lightroom and Capture One. The images you see below were not edited in any way and were exported from the respective softwares without modification – apart from the necessary, and from the perspective of this dynamic range and exposure analysis, irrelevant spatial downsizing and bandwidth-saving jpeg compression.
1. JPEG image comparisons (lightroom)
LR JPEG @ DR400
LR JPEG @ DR100
Move the slider left and right and observe how highlights overexposed at the dr100 setting are ‘pulled’ and preserved at dr400. (Images shot at ISO 1600)
The first part of the test was to see how Dynamic Range optimisation works. For the purpose that it was invented for, it worked great. Relative to DR100 already DR200 almost completely saved the highlights. DR400 took perfect care of them, no area of the image had any overexposure.
I started with the DR400 comparison to show you the full effect. Below is the comparison between DR100 and DR200.
LR JPEG @ DR200
LR JPEG @ DR100
The DR200 Dynamic Range setting already protected most of the highlights overexposed in the DR100 image. (Images shot at ISO 1600)
As the original scene was just mildly overexposed, the DR200 setting was also perfectly adequate in this case to deal with overexposure.
2. RAW image COMPARISONS (LIGHTROOM)
This is the part that I was really looking forward to. I am always happy to admit being wrong if it means that I learn something new. Perhaps my concept of what it means for a RAW image file to be unprocessed was mistaken and dynamic range compression happened before data got read out of the sensor.
Let’s take a look.
LR RAW @ DR400
LR RAW @ DR100
LOOK AS YOU MAY BUT THERE IS NO exposure or dynamic range difference whatsoever between the two images. (Images shot at ISO 1600)
I looked at all the RAW files from the each series. irrespective of the ISO or the Dynamic Range setting of the image the RAW images are identical.
Not seeing any shift in over- or underexposure, I sighed a huge sigh of relief as this result matched my expectations.
3. image COMPARISONS in Capture One
As an amateur but intrepid scientific explorer I though I’d take a look at the image in Capture One, as well. You never know! After all, we know that a RAW file can be processed in slightly different ways by various RAW engines.
First I took a look at the JPEGs.
CO JPEG @ DR400
CO JPEG @ DR100
The jpegs show the same level of change in capture one as they did in adobe lightroom. (Images shot at ISO 1600)
The JPEGs looked the same in Capture On as they did in Adobe Lightroom. Again, no surprise there as JPEGs are “ready meals” as opposed to all the cooking and baking that goes into preparing a RAW image.
What about the RAW originals?
CO RAW @ DR400
CO RAW @ DR100
The jpegs show the same level of change in capture one as they did in adobe lightroom. (Images shot at ISO 1600)
I was shocked! I still am shocked!
The fact the the RAW shot with a setting of DR400 has its highlights pulled is not good news. Just the contrary.
The RAW files underwent the same Dynamic Range optimisation process as the JPEGs. Had I stared with Capture One and, more importantly, had I been using Capture One exclusively, I may have concluded ages ago that DR200 and DR400 modify RAW files.
But they don’t. It’s only that Capture One reads the attribute recorded with RAW (“the camera was set to DR400 when I was created”) and applies it to the RAW file. This is actually pretty bad as – so far – I could find no obvious remedy to this. If this is an option, where do I disable it? If it’s not an option, well, it absolutely should be.
What does that mean for you, dear reader? That I will have to conduct a few more tests and see what other JPEG attributes that should be metadata are perhaps being treated as “fact” by the Capture One RAW engine!
Final conclusions - findings
1. Fujifilm’s DR setting compresses the highlights and lift the shadows a bit in JPEG images.
2. The DR setting does not affect RAW images.
3. This is not universally true in the sense that some image editing programs apply the DR flag of the JPEG to the RAW during processing. Adobe Lightroom does not apply it. Capture One does.
Further reading:
Boost Dynamic Range in Your Images. An excellent summary on Fujifilm cameras and the options for maximising dynamic range on the fujifilm-x.com site.
the video shows you the comparison of various Dynamic Range optimisation settings in Adobe Lightroom and Capture One.
